Field identification method

Cleavage versus fracture

Breakage pattern is often more reliable than color, but one shiny flat surface is not enough: cleavage must repeat with consistent orientation across the same mineral.

How can you tell cleavage from fracture?

Look for repeated, parallel break surfaces that recur in one or more directions. Cleavage follows structural weakness in a mineral; fracture is irregular breakage where no cleavage plane controls the surface. Crystal faces and cleavage surfaces are not the same thing.

Download LithoMapPut U.S. geology in your pocket.Choose Google Play or the App Store.

Principle

Why the test works

A crystal lattice may contain directions where atomic bonds are weaker. Breakage along those directions produces cleavage planes with repeatable geometry.

Minerals without useful cleavage may break by conchoidal, uneven, splintery, or earthy fracture. A sample can display both cleavage and fracture on different surfaces.

Procedure

How to perform the test

  1. 1

    Observe before breaking

    Rotate the specimen under a single light. Search existing chips for flat reflections that flash together.

  2. 2

    Find repetition

    A single plane may be a crystal face or accidental break. Cleavage is supported when several parallel surfaces recur through the same mineral.

  3. 3

    Count directions

    Group parallel planes as one direction. Then look for a second or third nonparallel set.

  4. 4

    Estimate angles

    Note whether directions meet near 90 degrees or at distinctly oblique angles. Do not demand perfect geometry from a rough hand sample.

  5. 5

    Record fracture too

    Describe curved shell-like, uneven, splintery, or earthy surfaces where cleavage is absent or interrupted.

Interpretation

How to read the result

One excellent direction; thin elastic or flexible sheets

Characteristic of mica-group minerals, though sheet behavior and color still matter.

Two directions near 90 degrees

Common in feldspars and pyroxenes. Striations, angle precision, color, and hardness help separate them.

Two directions near 60 and 120 degrees

Supports amphibole-group minerals such as hornblende.

Three directions at 90 degrees

Cubic cleavage, seen in minerals such as halite and galena.

Three directions not at 90 degrees

Rhombohedral cleavage, typical of calcite and dolomite.

Smooth curved, shell-like surfaces

Conchoidal fracture supports quartz or glass, but does not distinguish natural material from manufactured glass by itself.

Examples

Examples from the LithoMap guide library

Muscovite

One perfect basal cleavage that produces thin sheets.

Galena

Three excellent cleavage directions near 90 degrees.

Calcite

Three cleavage directions that form rhombohedra rather than cubes.

Quartz

No cleavage; commonly breaks with conchoidal fracture.

Troubleshooting

Common mistakes

  • Calling a crystal growth face cleavage
  • Counting each parallel surface as a separate direction
  • Judging the angle from one distorted chip
  • Assuming every shiny plane is cleavage
  • Breaking a specimen before inspecting surfaces that already exist
Safety and limits

Test safely

  • Prefer existing broken surfaces. Do not strike a specimen unless you own it, have permission, and can control flying chips.
  • Wear eye protection and keep other people clear of the work area.
  • Do not break fibrous, dusty, sulfide-rich, lead-bearing, radioactive, or culturally significant material.
  • Breakage is destructive and cannot prove a mineral identity on its own.

This method supports preliminary field identification. It is not laboratory confirmation, appraisal, hazard clearance, proof of origin, or permission to collect or alter a specimen.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Is a flat crystal face the same as cleavage?

No. A crystal face formed during growth; cleavage formed during breakage. Cleavage is identified by repeated parallel surfaces within broken material, not by flatness alone.

Can a mineral have both cleavage and fracture?

Yes. A break may follow cleavage in one area and cross the structure irregularly elsewhere, especially in small, intergrown, or weathered grains.

Why are cleavage angles approximate in hand samples?

Surfaces may be incomplete, stepped, altered, or partly hidden by other minerals. Use angle categories together with hardness, habit, and other properties.

Source basis

Authoritative sources

LithoMap wrote this guide in original language using the physical-property standards and safety information supported by these sources.

Editorial review: September 18, 2026.